East Kilbride FC v East Stirlingshire



Date Time League Season
3rd November 2018 15:00 Scottish Lowland Football League 2018-19


Club1st Half2nd HalfGoalsOutcome
East Kilbride FC022Win
East Stirlingshire000Loss


East Kilbride v East Stirlingshire 03/11/18 – Reporter: Ewan Malcolm

East Stirlingshire slumped to a comprehensive 2-0 defeat against East Kilbride at a windy K-Park on Saturday.

Derek Ure rubbished his side’s title chances this season telling the fanbase to “curb their enthusiasm”.  However, with his side a mere six points behind second placed East Kilbride the tie posed a real chance for Shire to close the gap and improve on a season that has been plagued with inconsistencies.

Similarly, Kilby were eager to put their first loss of the season against Civil Service Strollers behind them as they sought to keep within touching distance of Barry Ferguson’s Kelty Hearts.

Last season’s runners up started the brighter and could have taken an immediate lead when Sean Winter’s teasing cross crept narrowly wide of the onrushing Kilby attack.

Shire’s defence has been questionable at best so far this season, conceding 17 in their opening 10 games, however Ure would have been pleased to see his side hold firm in face of an early Kilby storm.

Having frustrated their hosts for large parts of the opening half, Shire grew in confidence and threatened to take the lead when Kris Faulds fired narrowly over from outside the box.

Shire, having put on something of a defensive masterclass in the first half, gave a stark reminder of their defensive frailty when the entire backline stood motionless as Paul Woods rounded Jamie Barclay before rolling the ball home.

The goal seemed to spark the hosts into life as they hit another shortly after through skipper Craig Malcolm who did well to divert the ball into the top corner on the slide after Shire’s defensive frailties made yet another unwanted cameo in a game where they had looked relatively solid.

Ure’s side were in danger of imploding spectacularly when Malcolm found himself through on goal again only to be denied by the feet of Barclay.

Shire faced an uphill task in producing a comeback against a defence that has only shipped six goals all season.  However, they very nearly found it when Andy Grant inexplicably blasted an effort over the bar with the goal at his mercy.

Grant’s miss proved pivotal as Kilby eased to a victory that condemns Shire to a defeat that leaves them in 11th place, 10 points adrift of leaders Kelty Hearts.

East Stirlingshire turn their attention towards the South of Scotland Cup next weekend where they will look to restore some confidence against Linlithgow Rose while East Kilbride can look forward to a trip to Gretna where they will hope to continue their pursuit of Kelty Hearts.


Match Details: Drummond Calder

East Stirlingshire: 1. Jamie Barclay 2. Connor Greene (CM) 3. Adam Murray (LB) 4. Danny Ashe (Captain) (RCD) 5. Chris McKee (LCD) 6. Andy Grant (RB) 7. Ross Allum (CF) 8. Kris Faulds (RCM) 9. Steven Brisbane (RM) 10. Paul McCafferty (LM) 11. Ludovic Erhard (LCM) Subs 12. Emmanuel Bitanga (not used) 14. Simon White (LCM) (came on for 11. Ludovic Erhard 75 mins) 15. Graeme MacGregor (not used) 16. David McCaughie (RM) (came on for 7. Ross Allum 70 mins) 18. Andy Rodgers (RF) (came on for 4. Danny Ashe 64 mins) 19. Trialist (not used)

East Kilbride: 1. Matthew McGinley 2. Scott Stevenson (RB) 3. Bernard Coll (LB) 4. Craig Howie (RCD) 5. David Proctor (LCD) 6. Graeme Holmes (LCM) 7. Michael Anderson (RCM) 8. Anton Brady (RM) 9. Craig Malcolm (LF) (Captain) 10. Sean Winter (RF) 11. Paul Woods (RM) Subs 12. Craig Reid (not used) 14. Fabio Capuano (not used) 15. Chris Humphrey (RM) (came on for 10. Sean Winter 76 mins) 16. Ross McNeill (not used) 17. Alfredo Agyeman (not used) 18. Jamie Longworth (RF) (came on for 8. Anton Brady 81 mins) 19. Trialist (not used)

Ht 0-0 Ft 0-2

East Stirlingshire Bookings – 1) Connor Greene (26 mins) 2) Kris Faulds (69 mins) 3) Chris McKee (87 mins)

East Kilbride Scorers – 1) Paul Woods (56 mins) 2) Craig Malcolm (67 mins)

East Kilbride Assists – 1) Anton Brady 2) Sean Winter

East Kilbride Bookings – 1) Paul Woods (36 mins) 2) Anton Brady (51 mins)

Crowd:  c.220

Referee: Matthew MacDermid

Assistant Referees: Chris Malone, David White



East Kilbride FC

East Kilbride FC

# Player Position Goals Assists Yellow Cards Red Cards
1Matt McGinleyGoalkeeper0000
2Scott StevensonDefender0000
3Bernard CollDefender0000
4Craig HowieDefender0000
5David ProctorDefender0000
6Graeme HolmesMidfielder0000
7Michael AndersonMidfielder0000
8Anton Brady 18Midfielder0110
9Craig MalcolmForward1000
10Sean Winter 15Forward0100
11Paul WoodsMidfielder1010
15Chris Humphrey 10Midfielder0000
18Jamie Longworth 8Forward0000

East Stirlingshire

# Player Position Goals Assists Yellow Cards Red Cards
1Jamie BarclayGoalkeeper0000
2Connor GreeneDefender, Midfielder0010
3Adam MurrayDefender0000
4Danny Ashe 18Defender0000
5Chris McKeeDefender0010
6Andy GrantDefender0000
7Ross Allum 16Forward0000
8Kris FauldsMidfielder0010
9Steven BrisbaneMidfielder, Forward0000
10Paul McCaffertyMidfielder0000
11Ludovic Erhard 14Midfielder0000
14Simon White 11Midfielder0000
16David McCaughie 7Midfielder0000
18Andy Rodgers 4Forward0000
Yellow Cards
Red Cards